The Art of Leaving a Year Unfinished

On liminality, the illusion of closure, and reclaiming our agency at the threshold of a new year

Every December, we are inundated from every angle with the belief that the previous twelve months need some kind of conclusion...

We’re told to look back on what we've accomplished, what we've lost, what we've learned, and what we want to leave behind.

We're encouraged to identify the lessons, celebrate our growth, and figure out what the year was supposed to mean before we enthusiastically welcome a new one.

It's a pretty ambitious expectation to place on an arbitrary point in Earth's orbit around the sun.

Don't get me wrong! I love a good ritual, and I understand the appeal (and even necessity, sometimes!) of a fresh start. Plus, there's something genuinely beautiful about collectively acknowledging the passage of time. But I find it interesting how easily that acknowledgment becomes an expectation that we should be ready to close one chapter of our lives simply because the calendar says it's time.

As though everything we've experienced since January should have reached some satisfying conclusion by December 31st.

And if it hasn't? Well, we'd better figure out what we're supposed to learn from it.

But what if we just... didn't?

A Year Is Not a Parable

A parable is a story constructed to communicate a lesson. The events within it exist to illustrate some larger truth, and by the time we reach the end, we're supposed to understand what it all meant.

But our lives don't always work that way.

Things happen to us, around us, and because of us. Some are wonderful, and some are devastating. Most are so ordinary and mundane that we barely register them while they're happening. And we spend an immense amount of time trying to make sense of all of it.

And there's nothing inherently wrong with that! Meaning-making is a deeply human activity, and the stories we tell about our experiences can help us understand ourselves and our relationships with the world.

But there's an important distinction between finding meaning in something and deciding that something happened for the purpose of teaching us a lesson.

Someone might lose a person they love and discover an entirely new capacity for compassion. That doesn't mean the person died to teach them compassion.

Someone might endure a terrible relationship and eventually build a beautiful life afterward. That doesn't make the suffering “necessary.”

And someone might make it through an entire year without experiencing some profound transformation. That doesn't mean they missed the point.

We can recognize what we've learned without turning every experience into an educational opportunity.

Our lives are not required to produce a moral.

The Business of Endings

Something especially fascinating about this time of year is the tension between the endings we've collectively agreed upon and the transitions happening in the natural world.

Here in the Northern Hemisphere, we're creeping up on the winter solstice in December. The days have been growing shorter, the landscape is settling into dormancy, and we're reaching the longest night of the year.

Then, almost imperceptibly after that transition, the light begins to return.

But winter won’t just be over. In many places, the coldest weather is still ahead (which I am not looking forward to based on 2027 predictions for my neck of the woods). The landscape doesn't suddenly spring back to life because we've crossed some astronomical threshold.

The darkness and the returning light coexist.

And there's something wonderfully liminal about that.

Liminality is often described as the space between what was and what will be. It's a threshold, a period of transition in which the familiar boundaries of our experience become a little less certain.

And I think we tend to misunderstand thresholds as distinct lines we're supposed to cross. One moment we're here, the next we're there. An ending, followed neatly by a beginning.

But the experience of being in transition is rarely so tidy.

We can be grieving and joyful. We can recognize that something has ended while continuing to live with its influence. We can be changing without knowing what we're changing into.

These experiences aren't necessarily contradictions that need resolving. They're part of the fluidity of being alive.

And yet, as the year draws to a close, we're surrounded by messages encouraging us to finalize, release, resolve, and begin again.

I wonder how much of our end-of-year anxiety comes from trying to force our internal experiences into a structure that doesn't actually reflect how we're living them.

When Reflection Becomes an Obligation

We can recogize there is a distiction between reflecting on our experiences and feeling obligated to extract something useful from them.

Reflection allows us to pay attention. It gives us an opportunity to notice what we've experienced, how we've responded, and what we might want to carry forward.

But when reflection becomes compulsory, it starts to look more like a performance review.

Did you grow enough?

Did you accomplish enough?

Did you learn the lesson?

Have you finally become the person you were supposed to become this year?

And if you're grieving, exhausted, uncertain, or just not feeling particularly transformed, that kind of inventory can make an already complicated season feel even heavier.

I've talked before about how grief doesn't owe us a redemption arc. We don't have to turn loss into wisdom or suffering into strength to justify having experienced it.

The same is true of our lives more broadly.

You can appreciate what an experience taught you without being grateful that it happened. You can acknowledge that something changed you without deciding the change was necessarily for the better.

And you can leave a question unanswered without treating that uncertainty as a personal failure.

This is where the concept of agency becomes especially important.

Agency Isn't the Same Thing as Control

When we talk about having agency over our lives, it's easy to confuse that with having control over our circumstances.

But so much of the human experience exists beyond our control.

We can't dictate when grief will soften, how other people will behave, or when an experience will finally make sense to us. And we definitely can't demand that the universe organize itself around our preferred timelines… (though, wouldn’t that be nice?)

What we can do is become more conscious of how we participate in what's happening.

That's a fundamental part of my philosophy, both personally and in my work as a death doula.

I don't believe our relationship with the world is purely passive, nor do I believe we're somehow separate from the larger systems and cycles we're participating in. We're part of them. Our choices, interpretations, and actions contribute to the ongoing experience of being alive.

And agency lives in that participation.

Sometimes it means taking action. Sometimes it means changing our perspective, questioning an expectation we've inherited, or deciding that a particular ritual no longer serves us.

And sometimes it means choosing to let something remain exactly as unresolved as it is.

I often invite people who are grieving to consider a question: What is your grief asking of you?

It's not a question with a predetermined answer. Sometimes grief asks for movement, connection, or expression. Sometimes it asks for rest. Sometimes we don't know what it's asking at all.

None of the above are wrong.

The practice is in listening rather than automatically imposing an expectation on the experience.

I think we can approach the end of the year in much the same way.

Rather than asking what we're supposed to have accomplished, released, or understood by now, we can consider what we actually need from this transition.

And we can allow the answer to be different from whatever the rest of the world seems to be doing.

Leaving the Year Unfinished, on Purpose

There's a temptation to treat unfinished things as evidence that we've failed to complete something.

But what if incompleteness isn't always a problem?

What if it's simply an acknowledgment that we're still participating in an experience whose meaning continues to evolve?

The stories we tell about our lives change as we do. Something that felt insignificant five years ago might carry enormous meaning today. A loss that once seemed impossible to live alongside might become part of how we understand ourselves, without ever becoming less important.

We don't have to decide what every experience means while we're still in the middle of living with it.

And we sure as shit don't have to do it before midnight on December 31st.

Leaving a year unfinished can be an intentional practice of allowing our lives to remain open to possibility. It doesn't mean refusing to reflect, abandoning our goals, or pretending that endings don't exist.

It means recognizing that a calendar turning over doesn't require us to arrive at some definitive conclusion about who we are or what we've experienced.

We can honor the threshold without demanding that it transform us.

We can participate in the rituals that feel meaningful and decline the ones that don't.

And we can carry our unfinished stories into the next year without apologizing for them.

The Art of Remaining Open

Personally, I find something deeply comforting and beautiful about the idea that we are always in some state of becoming.

Not because we're perpetually incomplete people who need to be improved, but because being alive means continuing to participate in a world that never stops changing.

The natural world doesn't demand that every transition resolve itself according to a convenient schedule. The light begins returning while winter is still very much underway.

We can allow ourselves that same spaciousness.

As this year comes to an end, I invite you to consider what it might feel like to leave some of it unfinished.

You don't need to decide what every experience taught you. You don't have to resolve every contradiction or turn every difficult moment into something useful.

You can acknowledge what happened, recognize what remains uncertain, and allow yourself to continue living with both.

The calendar will turn. The seasons will continue their movement. And we'll carry on participating in whatever strange, beautiful, complicated business it is to be alive.

There will be time to understand things differently.

For now, perhaps the most intentional thing we can do is leave a little room for what we don't yet know.

Next
Next

The Geography of Grief; why Grief Feels Like Learning to Live in a New World